Dupe Alert: NARS Albatross Vs. E.L.F. Gotta Glow

Posted by Lipglossiping On October - 1 - 2010

The comparisons have to be made don’t they?  At just £3.50 for the pale gold E.L.F Gotta Glow compared to £19.50 for NARS iconic Albatross highlighting powder… who isn’t hoping for a remarkable dupe?

The NARS on the left.. E.L.F’s Gotta Glow, on the right.

I’m not gonna talk about the differences in packaging.  They’re there… NARS is annoying and icky sticky, E.L.F’s is sleeker but hella cheaper looking.  Do you *really* care?  I don’t.

But what about the product?

E.L.F’s Gotta Glow is slightly more yellow toned in appearance and the gold shimmer is less refined looking in the pan… chunkier.  This is pretty much what I expected.  On close inspection, you can see a visual difference in quality.

The texture?  Again… this lives up to expectations.

NARS Albatross is smooth and very finely milled… there’s no flaking when you brush the surface of the pan and no fall out upon application.  The E.L.F version can’t claim the same.  It’s powdery and there is fall out if you don’t give your brush a tap off before applying.

But how about this?  Please look past the hairy arms… I have enough hair elsewhere on my body to frankly give a crap about hairy forearms.

That’s pretty simillar no?

Take a guess before reading on… which one costs £3.50 and which one costs £19.50?  I’d love for you to tell me if you got it right in the comments…

.

.

Ready to find out?

.

.

Sure?

.

.

Oh ok… Well… E.L.F’s Gotta Glow is on the left and NARS Albatross is on the right.  I think that I can tell the difference between the swatches… the E.L.F one looks slightly less pigmented and a bit ‘chunkier’.  But is that *really* a £16 difference?  Not when you take into consideration that once applied and blended… I truly struggle to tell the difference on my face at all.

Before I get really excited though… there is one point to note that although not an issue for my skintone, may make ALL the difference on someone else.  I see a slight ashiness with the E.L.F incarnation that I’m not seeing with the NARS original.  It’s only noticeable when I swatch on my fingertip… but I’m thinking that on a darker skintone, the E.L.F Gotta Glow may leave a slight white cast along with the golden sheen.

Has anyone tried it with a darker skintone than mine?  How are you finding E.L.F’s new Gotta Glow highlighting powder?

E.L.F Gotta Glow is available online and priced at £3.50 – a bargain if ever I saw one.


24 Responses to “Dupe Alert: NARS Albatross Vs. E.L.F. Gotta Glow”

  1. Sophie says:

    Wow, Impressive.. I thought the swatches were the other way around. I wanna check this out xx

  2. Thanks for this. Had been looking to buy this for ages but thought, why? Won’t it just make me all shimmery and glittery? For £3.50 I’ll take the plunge.

  3. D says:

    I got it right :)

    Pretty simillar though and the slight difference isn’t worth £16 to me.

  4. Impressive!! :) Thanks for the swatches! :)

  5. I have the ELF version, unaware that it was a Nars dupe- I just wanted a nice highlighter for my super pale skin! I have yet to try it though, because frankly, I was a bit bummed at the gold tone (which, on my skin, looks gold, not highlighting.) I’d be intersted to hear how this looks on deep skin-I’ll try it myself as soon as I get the chance!

  6. ashley says:

    I thought it was the opposite. gosh, the ELF one looks better to me.

  7. Wow! Surprisingly I got it right! I have been wanting to get the ELF powder for a while! I think I just might do it now.

    BTW, you’re too funny about “Please look past the hairy arms”- anytime I do swatches, I always think “OMG, people are gonna look at my hairy arms!”

  8. sherrie says:

    WoW! great review I have the ELF one on my wish list x

  9. I could tell the differences in the swatches based on quality but I think once blended the elf would work really nicely. Especially as I don’t think I could justify spending that much on the NARS version. Love your blog, one of the highlights of my day!

  10. Wow, that’s impressive! Thanks for letting us know!

  11. Lisa says:

    ELF’s is chunkier and slightly more gold but good enough! You could buy a different NARS blush instead and I do have my eye on Deep Throat…

  12. Louise says:

    I guessed right, great comparison :)
    x

  13. liz says:

    Glad I guessed correctly since I only recently shelled out on the Nars. However I’m super happy with it having used the No7 LE shimmer and being dissapointed with it. I may be strange, but I like the Nars packaging, what can I say I must have thing about rubber…

  14. Jan says:

    I got it wrong wrong wrong, but then anything with a hint of yellow makes me look yellow. Nice pics. Jan

  15. Bernice says:

    Yep got it right :)
    But I’m fairly light so I don’t think I’ll splurge on the NARS.

    Great review as always, Charlotte!

  16. SoFroLushes says:

    Maybe its time I finally put together my ELF order. I have wanted Albatross for a long time. I am concerned if it will do an ashy thing but but I am sure I can make it work somehow.

  17. kia says:

    yay i guessed correctly! thanks for the comparison!

  18. Rebecca says:

    Oooh, I think for personal use I’d totally go down the ELF road. I have to say though, for my kit and use on shoots, etc I’d have to go the NARS. Just because I need to be quick and have complete confidence in the products I’m using. For that reason I couldn’t go past NARS and the ELF just needs too much work. xxx

  19. […] Love NARS makeup but not the price tag? Lipglossiping signals the “dupe alert” siren when she shows off a serious but affordable dupe for NARS Albatross! […]

  20. […] Love NARS makeup but not the price tag? Lipglossiping signals the “dupe alert” siren when she shows off a serious but affordable dupe for NARS Albatross! […]

  21. […] Love NARS makeup but not the price tag? Lipglossiping signals the “dupe alert” siren when she shows off a serious but affordable dupe for NARS Albatross! […]

  22. […] нашла показательные свотчи на эти румяна-хайлайтер тут и тут, и в обоих вариантах блогеры склоняются к тому, […]

Leave a Reply

RANDOM

Create an Original with The Body Shop Competition

To celebrate the re-introduction of some long-lost favourites, The Body Shop are asking YOU to ‘Create an Original’. If you could bottle a scent, what …

Inexpensive Beauty Find: H&M Wintersky Nail Polish

Loves me a good duochrome I do! The problem with some duochromes is that no matter how delightfully galactic they look in the bottle, once …

The Lipstick Leauge - Week of 25.07.11

Question of the Week: – What’s your favorite skincare line? Answer: Elemis because their products are an unadulterated pleasure to use but I’m currently really …

Scoop Alert!!

I have a VERY exciting UK exclusive coming up tomorrow… I’m making all kinds of “squee” noises over this one! Don’t miss it! I won’t …

Anxiety

I’m going to write about something that’s a bit out of character for me.  I’m not really sure why I feel a compulsion to do …

Avon Luxe Lace Christmas Collection - Lace Hues Palette

I was going to do one post that encompassed the entire Christmas Collection, but for the life of me, I couldn’t get a colour-accurate tube …

Helena Rubinstein Stellars Showlights Lipstick

Hello my pretty! I discovered her hiding under a pile of soaps at my local T.K. Maxx… let me introduce you to “Bubble Pink” as …

Precision Nails R03 – VIP Very Important Polish

Looking for something vampy, glossy and with just a hint of purple? Precision Nails in shade R03 VIP Very Important Polish might be what you’ve …

Carolyn K Armineh NOTD

If you’re a fan of classic shades, Carolyn K’s Armineh is about as classic as it gets.  This beige-toned nude should work well on most …

Red Lip Series: Revlon Cherries in the Snow

I don’t know how I feel about including this lipstick in my red lip series. I mean, it’s totally like the lipstick angels came down …

POPULAR

CLOSED: Competition Time: Givenchy Very Irresistible L'eau en Rose Perfume!

Want to really spoil Mum this Mother’s Day?  Or perhaps you just want to spoil yourself?  It’s ok… I won’t judge… there are plenty of …

CLOSED - Win it! The Body Shop Expert Brush Collection

I don’t know about you, but I woke up this morning with a distinct “Hello Monday morning, I’ve been expecting you…” kinda feeling.  Maybe it’s …

Win a gorgeous "glow" trio with prizes from Urban Decay, New CID, & Arbonne!

COMPETITION NOW CLOSED! WINNER IS: “IZABELLA” (COMMENT #96045) – WINNER HAS BEEN EMAILED!   It’s still January, the MET office have just issued yet another …

Hello? Is this thing on?

Phew, that was a little unexpected. For those of you who haven’t had the misfortune of reading my hand-wringing tweets and woe-ridden facebook updates, let …

Big savings on French Pharmacy brands, win my Escentual.com top picks!

I’m of the firm opinion that for the money, French pharmacy brands offer some of the best solutions for diffcult skin-types. Escentual.com have long been …

Avoid the brush off with Oral-B Pro-Expert

There’s a new toothpaste in town. It’s lean, mean and err not very minty as it happens.  Featuring the revolutionary bacteria-busting ingredient Stabilised Stannous Flouride, …

Win it! 3 EcoTools Bamboo Bronzer Brushes to win!

I’ve written about these before, you know I love them, I want you to love them too! So why not have a go at winning …

FOTD Busting out of the comfort zone!

You may recall my bitter moans last week about how when presented with a rare opportunity to spend an indecent amount of time playing with …

Dear Obesity...

We have been together for over 20 years, our lives so entwined that I’ve never been sure how to live without you.  I would like …

Urban Decay The Black Palette - Photos & Swatches

The soon-to-be-released Black Palette from US eyeshadow maestro’s Urban Decay is an altogether darker affair than the recent Naked set… The Black Palette includes 6, …

  • Categories

  • Archives

  • Admin

  • Ads